8 mins read

Why Top Online Reviewers Retain Influence Despite Losing Status

What happens when online reviewers lose their top status? How does it affect quality of new posts, and how do other users perceive this?
Why Top Online Reviewers Retain Influence Despite Losing Status
November 10, 2025
Listen to this article
Vandith Pamuru
Assistant Professor of Information Systems. His research focuses on user engagement in online platforms and the design of incentives, particularly in the context of emerging technologies.
Key Takeaways
  • Demoted reviewers on UGC platforms tend to write reviews of significantly lower quality. 
  • Although the content quality of reviews tends to drop after demotion, other users on the platform continue to perceive these as helpful. 
  • Display of demoted contributor’s previously held status could have negative consequences for the platform.